Yesterday I did a quick post on iTunes U here at Penn State -- really it was a plea for help on meta data management ... but, since we have not really announced iTunes U in a formal way I think it has started an interesting question, what do we do with our own Podcasts at Penn State site now? I had originally posted this as a reply to the comment on yesterday's post, but it got me thinking about the question of iTunes U vs Rolling Your Own ...
It is a good question and one that we are constantly tossing back and forth. On one hand, having developed our own space gives us the opportunity to innovate on our terms -- that is a good thing. On the other hand Apple is good at this stuff and is likely to continue to create new thinking in the space that we may be just playing catch up to. If I did a balanced score card -- not a bad idea -- I think at the moment it would come out tipping towards iTunes U. The lure of not having to maintain and grow yet another service (YAS) for my team is a very attractive alternative.
At the moment the Podcasts at Penn State site does not give us an authenticated podcast space ... in other words, if you post it in our space anyone can see it. That doesn't matter to me, but for the vast majority of faculty that doesn't fly. iTunes U is by nature a secure podcasting platform -- obviously we can control the public v private content, but it is much more like a CMS/LMS toolset. Some have criticized Apple for creating a "walled garden," but in the realities of higher education it is the model people are used to and seemingly prefer. I see a day somewhere in the future where we can open this stuff up, but we aren't there yet.
Our vision for the Podcasts at Penn State site are to move it to a "podcasting hub" of sorts -- a place where faculty, staff, and (eventually) students can go to learn how to podcast, get equipment recommendations, listen to sample podcasts, collect lesson ideas, discuss how they are using podcasts, and other applied things that support the appropriate use of the technology. When our Fall pilot is over, I envision posting the final report there as well. Could it grow into a home for a community of practice? I also see it as a space that will evolve into a directory to highlight the best content at Penn State on iTunes U. I wonder what others would like to see?
Can it be compared to where we all were 10 years ago with the LMS/CMS decisions that we were facing? A lot of people set out to build their own, a lot of people just sort of hung back and waited, and a lot of people went out and bought WebCT, FirstClass, or whatever at the time. I'm not sure it is the same thing, but I have been through the, "let's build our own solution" cycle too many times and with something as potentially complex (and popular) as this I have to ask myself if it is worth it. I would much rather be in the business of inspiring and supporting the appropriate use of technology for teaching and learning and leave the heavy lifting of designing, developing, and supporting enterprise applications to the big boys. At the end of the day I just hate it when something jumps up and bites me in the ass -- for either building or buying. What is the right long term move? Good question ...